It's been 4 years since I started Smellthis.net. Square/Weebly, my webhosting service just DOUBLED their monthly fee. Please consider DONATING via PAYPAL or DONATING VIA SQUARE/WEEBLY For Video Reviews, vist The Candle Queen Youtube Channel Please like, share, and subscribe! *If you appreciate my DUPES lists, a donation will help me keep making them. It takes a lot of time & effort to compile these lists. I do all this because I know I would use a site like this. I figured, why not make it? There must be more people like me out there somewhere. Maybe they're looking for the perfect candles? A discontinued favorite candle? I hope whatever you came here for, you find it. **Post any requests to deep dive for a certain dupe (or if u know of one i haven't posted) by leaving a comment here or on my Dupes & Repackages Page. This site wouldn't be possible without the stellar reviews, suggestions, and DONATIONS from people like YOU -thank you for all your help! ~ The Candle Queen 💛 **** PLEASE DO NOT REPOST OR SELL THIS LIST WITHOUT MY EXPLICIT PERMISSION. IT TAKES ME MONTHS, AND IN SOME CASES YEARS TO COMPILE ALL THIS DATA, AS WELL AS TRACK DOWN DUPES FOR THE CANDLE KINGDOM. I HATE HAVING TO POST THIS, BUT SOME PEOPLE ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THE FACT I'VE POSTED INFO FOR FREE. THEY ARE LITERALLY COPYING, PASTING, AND MAKING MONEY OFF MY HARD WORK. YOU ARE WELCOME TO USE THIS INFORMATION RECREATIONALLY, BUT PLEASE LINK BACK TO SMELLTHIS.NET AND GIVE CREDIT TO THE CANDLE QUEEN. THAT'S ALL I ASK ****** I DO THIS OUT OF LOVE 💗 it never feels like the right time to drop a dupes list because it's an ongoing project. My last Goose Creek Dupes list was 2 years ago. there's no time like the present so here's my Goose Creek Dupes List 2024.
Dupes: ⦁ GC Amazing Grace = GC Grace ⦁ GC Autumn Romance = GC Perfect Day ⦁ GC Baking a Cake = GC Be Still = GC Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake/GC Zebra Cakes ⦁ GC Balsam Fir = BBW Fresh Balsam ⦁ GC Banana Nut Muffin = GC Sweet Banana Bread ⦁ GC Blessed Day = YC Apple Pumpkin ⦁ GC Boardwalk Cone = GC Wild Berry & Waffles ⦁ GC Boardwalk Mahogany = BBW Mahogany Coconut ⦁ GC Boy Tears = GC Late Night ⦁ GC Blueberry Cheesecake = GC Blueberry Pie With Cream ⦁ GC Blueberry Pancakes = BBW Blueberry Maple Pancakes ⦁ GC Bread & Milk = Fresh Baked Bread = Germany ⦁ GC Breezy Tulips = YC Tulips ⦁ GC Brewed Coffee/Coffee = World's Best Cup of Coffee ⦁ GC Broom Squad = GC Creepy Critters = GC Campfire Marshmallows = GC Warm Vanilla Woods = BBW Marshmallow Fireside/Smoky Vanilla ⦁ GC Buddy the Elf = GC Sugar Cookie Milkshake ⦁ GC Butter Brittle/Gramma Nut/Yum = BBW Pumpkin Peanut Brittle ⦁ GC Butterscotch Cupcake = GC Butterscotch Cake Pop ⦁ GC Button-Up = GC Flannel = BBW Black Tie ⦁ GC Cafe Ole = GC Irish Cream Swirl ⦁ GC Candied Easter Eggs = GC Christmas Candy ⦁ GC Candy Cane Forest = GC Mr. Mint = GC Vanilla Snow Angels ⦁ GC Candy Cottage = BBW Be Mine/Candy Hearts/Pink Fairy Gumdrop = GC Jolly ⦁ GC Candy Land = GC Cotton Candy Blizzard ⦁ GC Caramel Apple Lane / GC Caramel Applewood = BBW Cider Lane/Spooky Cider Lane ⦁ GC Caramel Pecan Pie = GC Caramel Butter ⦁ GC Carnival Apple = GC Carnival Candy Apple ⦁ GC Carrot Cake Pop = GC Carrot Cake Pop = GC Fall Party Cakes ⦁ GC Champagne Bubbles/Celebrate = GC Champagne Sparkle = GC Date Night = BBW Champagne Toast /You Are Loved ⦁ GC Cherry Cobbler = BBW Sugared Cherry Crisp ⦁ GC Chilly Creek Water = GC Chilly Rain Showers ⦁ GC Choco Puffs = GC Crazy Choco Circles ⦁ GC Christmas Cakes = GC Christmas Tree Cakes = Vanilla Birthday Cake = Vanilla Cake Pop = Warm Vanilla Cake ⦁ GC Cinnamon Sugar Ice Cream/Cinnamon Sugar Vanilla/Honey Buns/Sugar Cookie Snack/White Icing Cinnamon Roll = = BBW Cinnamon Spriced Vanilla/ Cinnamon Sugar Donut ⦁ GC Cinnamon Sugar Ice Cream = GC Cinnamon Sugar Vanilla = GC Honey Buns = GC Sugar Cookie Snack = GC White Icing Cinnamon Roll ⦁ GC Citrus & Ginger = BBW Orange Ginger / Energy ⦁ GC Coconut & Sandalwood / Awaken = GC Coconut Sandalwood / Peaceful ⦁ GC Cookie Cream Pudding = GC Cookies & Cream Ice Cream = GC Penguin Cookie & Cream = BBW Marble Chocolate Cupcake ⦁ GC Cookie Monster = GC Bunny Cookie ⦁ GC Cool Harvest Morning = BBW Autumn ⦁ GC Cosmic Brownies = GC Homemade Brownies = GC Warm Fudge Cupcake ⦁ GC Crunchy Leaves = BBW Leaves ⦁ GC Custard = GC Queen Frostine (QF a little richer/stronger buttercream - same notes) ⦁ GC Dutch Stroopwafels = GC Stroopwafels / Netherlands ⦁ GC Easter Bunny = GC Melt My Heart ⦁ GC Easter Morning = GC Easter Sunday Dress ⦁ GC Eucalyptus & Mint = BBW Eucalyptus Spearmint = BBW Eucalyptus Mint ⦁ GC Eucalyptus Mist = GC Eucalyptus Rain Drops ⦁ GC Fireplace = BBW Fireside ⦁ GC Forest Pine Trees = Throne of Lies ⦁ GC French Toast/Bless Your Heart = GC Maple Syrup ⦁ GC Fresh Baked Bread / Germany = BBW French Baugette ⦁ GC Fruity Cereal Fun = GC Silly Tricks ⦁ GC Green Apple (OE) = GC Wild Green Apple ⦁ GC Jelly Beans = GC Marshmallow Macaroons / France ⦁ GC Key Lime Cake Pop = BBW Key Lime Pie = BBW Marshmallow Cereal Bar = BBW Rainbow Confetti ⦁ GC Lavender Vanilla = Lush Sleepy ⦁ GC Lemon Leaves = GC Lemon & Olive Leaf ⦁ GC Love Letters = YC Blush Bouquet ⦁ GC Marshmallow Happiness = GC Lucky Marshmallows ⦁ GC Marshmallow Macaroon/France = GC Jelly Beans ⦁ GC Marshmallow Monsters = GC Spooky Buddies ⦁ GC Midnight Berry = BBW Vampire Blood ⦁ GC North Pole Magic = BBW In the Stars ⦁ GC Old Time Lemonade = GC Limencello = YC Country Lemonade ⦁ GC Papaya Paradise = BBW Island Papaya ⦁ GC Peach Cobbler Donut = Peach Pecan Waffles ⦁ GC Peppermint Clouds = GC Peppermint Whip ⦁ GC Perfect Day = GC Autumn Romance ⦁ GC Picnic Blanket = YC Warm Luxe Cashmere ⦁ GC Pile of Leaves = BBW Sweater Weather II (body care)( ⦁ GC Pink Beach = YC Pink Sands ⦁ GC Pink Lemonade Easter Eggs = GC Strawberry Lemonade Cupcake ⦁ GC Poison Berry Potion = GC Boo Berry Potion ⦁ GC Pumpkin Breakfast Waffles = BBW Pumpkin Pecan Waffles ⦁ GC Pumpkin Cupcake = GC Pumpkin Delights ⦁ GC Red White & Blue = BBW Firecracker Pop ⦁ GC Rose Petal Icing = BBW Pink Petal Tea Cake (Candle Queen tested – RPI is better IMO) ⦁ GC Scarlet Apple = Yankee Candle Macintosh ⦁ GC Snickerdoodles For Santa = GC Sugared Snickerdoodle ⦁ GC Snow Covered Apple = BBW Winter Candy Apple (Candle Queen tested) ⦁ GC Sour Candy Martini = GC Franken Fizz ⦁ GC Spiced Fallen Leaves = BBW Leaves ⦁ GC Strawberry Cupcake = GC Strawberry Sponge Cake = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake ⦁ GC Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream = GC Strawberry Sponge Cake Ice Cream ⦁ GC Summer Moon = YC Midsummer's Night ⦁ GC This is Christmas = BBW The Perfect Christmas ⦁ GC Tree Cutting = BBW Sweater Weather ⦁ GC Tree Farm = YC Christmas Eve ⦁ GC Under a Spell = VS Love Spell ⦁ GC Vanilla Sands = Scentsy Vanilla Waves (VS is softer) ⦁ GC Vanilla Snowman = White Chocolate Buttercream ⦁ GC Village Pumpkin Festival = BBW Apple Pumpkin = YC Apple Pumpkin ⦁ GC Watermelon Lemonade = GC Melon Lemonade ⦁ GC Whipped Vanilla Dreams = BBW Whipped Vanilla Chiffon ⦁ GC Witch's Cauldron = YC Witches Brew Dupes: Close/Unconfirmed GC Arctic Pine = GC Forest of Trees/Throne of Lies (90% sure these are dupes) GC Auburn Lake = GC Lakeside Leaves (80% sure these are dupes - mandarin/currant/balsam) GC Autumn Walk = BBW Ebony Sands = BBW Tobacco Flower (near dupe -as close as it gets) GC Balsam Fir = YC Balsam & Cedar (gc reviewer fave YC scent – says GC is better) GC Beautiful Creatures = GC Sugar Plum Kiss (nearly identical fragrance notes) GC Bergamot Mist = YC Midsummers Night (BM is lighter) GC Black Cherry = BBW Black Cherry Merlot (near identical notes but BC sweeter +spun sugar) *GC Blueberry Greek Yogurt = *GC Blueberry Jam (nearly identical notes -80% sure of dupe) *GC Boardwalk Candy = *King Kandy (80% sure double sugar/suckers/cotton candy/strawberry) *GC Boardwalk Cone = *GC Very Berry (according to a GC reviewer these are dupes) GC Book By The Lake = GC Lakeside Breeze (nearly identical fragrance notes LB+ lemon) *GC Boy Tears/Late Night = Fresh Shave (70% dupe woodsy floral/fresh citrus musk) GC Brew Potion = GC Witches Cauldron (multiple SPECIFIC fragrance notes) *GC Butterscotch Ripple = GC Sweet Potato Marshmallow (80% dupe -they share 4/5 notes) GC Campfire Cuddle = GC Cozy With You (all but mid notes, match) GC Candied Valentine Cookies = GC Velvet Santa Cookies (80% cookie dough, berry, vanilla icing) GC Candy Cane = GC Candy Cane Kiss (candy cane + chocolate) *GC Candy Land Cupcake = *GC Magical World of Candy (both smell like tootsie rolls) GC Canteen Hot Cocoa = GC Easter Bunny /Melt My Heart *GC Chamomile & Spruce = *GC Lavender & Chamomile (75% dupe - L&C has all C&S notes) GC Cherry Cobbler = BBW Sugared Cherry Crisp *GC Chocolate Chip Cookie = *GC Fudge Rounds (75% dupe - cookie, fudge, cocoa) *GC Chocolate Chip Cookies = *GC Christmas Tree Brownies GC Christmas Cookies = GC Sugar Cookie Milkshake/Buddy the Elf (share most fragrance notes) GC Cider & Sweaters = This is Autumn (oats, leaves,apples, spices in common) GC Cinnamon Pumpkin = BBW Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin (V. Similar-need to confirm its a dupe) *GC Cinnamon Pumpkin = *GC Classic Pumpkin (CP has added orange note) *GC Cinnamon Sugar Ice Cream /Cinnamon Sugar Vanilla = *GC Cinnamon Sugar Swirl (nearly identicle fragrance notes) *GC Classic Christmas Tree = *YC Christmas Wreath (authentic fresh cut, heady pine scent) *GC Coconut Beechwood = *BBW Coconut Mahogany (according to gc reviewer) GC Coffee House* = GC Coffee Shop = GC Turkish Coffee/Turkey GC Colorful Leaves = BBW The Perfect Autumn (CL weaker throw) *GC Crunchy Leaves = *GC Spiced Fallen Leaves (both smell like BBW Leaves) GC Marshmallows/Spooky Buddies = Sonoma Toasted Marshmallow GC Custard/Queen Frostine = Custard Cream Cake (probably a dupe - similar notes) GC Dazzling Popcorn = BBW Summer Boardwalk (most likely a dupe - 2xs comparison) *GC Dream Clouds = *GC Fruity Hoops (80% sure of dupe *GC Emerald Palm = *GC Tropical Daydream (70% dupe -pineapple/apple/woods/palm) *GC Everlasting Gobstopper = *GC Forbidden Elixer (80% dupe - citrus/sour/cotton candy) *GC Forest = *GC In the Forest (according to 1 gc reviewer's nose, VERY similar notes) *GC French Autumn = *BBW Vampire Blood (according to 1 gc reviewer) *GC Garden Strawberries = *GC Rain Drenched Strawberries (60% dupe half of notes different) GC Ghost Stories = Midnight Cookie Craving (very similar notes- soft caramel + butter + cookie) *GC Grapefruit = *YC Juicy Grapefruit *GC Homemade Cherry Pie = *GC Mrs. Rabbit's Homemade Pie *GC Honolulu Ice Cream = *GC Pineapple Cake Pop (90% sure this is a dupe) *GC Island Bliss = *KC Fiji *GC Jasmine Cabana = GC With Love (citrus/tropical/jasmine/lily/woods - 70% dupe) *GC Lavender Twilight = *GC Blueberry Cream *GC Lemon Meringue (SS) = *BBW Iced Lemon Poundcake *GC Lickable Wallpaper = *GC Melon Picnic = *GC Watermelon Sugar Icy Pop (70% dupe watermelon/apple/sugar) GC Mahogany Boardwalk = BBW Mahogany Coconut *GC Mr. Mint/Candy Cane Forest/Vanilla Snow Angels = *BBW Crushed Candy Cane (SBND) GC Peppermint Clouds/ Peppermint Whip = BBW Twisted Peppermint (no eucalyptus note) *GC Pink Bellini = BBW Peach Bellini (BBW has stronger peach note) *GC Pumpkin Pound Cake = BBW Pumpkin Cinnamon Bun (PPC stronger bakery note) *GC Pumpkin Sugar Cookie = *BBW Pumpkin Snickerdoodle *GC Rainbow Candied Sugar/Rainbow Sugar = *GC Care Bears: Shar GC Sage Leaf & Citrus = YC Citrus & Sage (SL&C stronger w/ more sage/mint tea scent) *GC Strawberry Jell = *GC Summer Slices GC Sunday Drive = BBW Cactus Blossom (SD has added raspberry note) *GC Sugar Cookie = *GC Sugar Cookie Dough *GC Sugar Cookie Milkshake = *Swan Creek Saturday Morning Cereal & Milk (almost idential) *GC Sugared Donut = *BBW Cinnamon Caramel Swirl (both smell like fried ice cream) *GC Tree Cutting = *BBW Sweater Weather (SBND xmas tree + mint+ eucalyptus TC xtra pine) GC Vanilla Birthday Cake = BBW Sprinkled Birthday Cake (VBC slightly sweeter) *GC Vanilla Tobacco & Amber = *GC Vanilla Tobacco (repackage or nearly identical) *GC Warm Kiss = *BBW Wild Madagascar Vanilla GC Watermelon Bubblegum = BBW Watermelon Lemonade GC Whipped Vanilla Dreams = BBW Whipped Vanilla Chiffon *GC White Coral = *BBW Pink Chiffon Smells like.... GC 11 Cookies in the VCR = Gigerbread Cookies + Sugar Cookies GC Apple Pumpkin = GC Village Pumpkin Festival (SBND) GC Apple Stacks = Kellogs Apple Jacks Cereal GC Apricot = Secret Apricot Deodorant (according to GC reviewer) GC Autumn Apple = Baked apples/Applesauce GC Autumn Wreath = GC Colorful Leaves (SBND- CL has more leaves/wood smell) GC Autumn Romance = GC Perfect Day = VS Love Spell GC Autumn Walk = Gold Canyon Autumn Walk GC Backroad Blooms = Backwoods of Northwest Mississippi in the Spring GC Baked Bread = BBW French Baugette GC Banana Cabana Beach = Banana Boat Sunscreen = Sun Bum Leave-In Conditioner Spray Detangler (banana + coconut) GC Banana Marshmallow Ice Cream = Banana Moon Pies GC Be My Boo = GC Strawberry Cake Pop (SBND) GC Beach Vibes = “Yummy Melons” & Pineapple GC Bergamot & Tea Leaves = BBW White Tea & Ginger (SBND – close enough tea/floral/clean scent) GC Bergamot Mist = BBW Bergamot Woods (SBND) GC Black Cat = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (SBND-BC lighter/sweeter/more musk) GC Black Pepper = Trapps Black Pepper = YC Candlelit Cabin (BP more cologne/peppery) GC Blessed Day = BBW Leaves (SBND) GC Brew Potion = GC Haunted Forest (SBND) GC Brew Potion = Theirry Mugler Angel Perfume GC Broom Squad/Creepy Critters = GC Campfire Marshmallow = BBW Marshmallow Fireside/Smoky Vanilla GC Butter Pecan Ice Cream = BBW Pumpkin Pecan Waffles (SBND – lighter/more pleasant according to GC site reviewer) GC Button Up/Flannel = Ralph Lauren Polo GC Cabin Getaway = BBW White Tea & Sage = H20 Green Tea Perfume (SBND – WT&S + CG = similar sage notes) GC California Coast = Versace Eau Fraiche Cologne (SBND – familiar warm notes) GC Campfire Marshmallow = BBW Marshmallow Fireside/Smoky Vanilla (CM is more sweet/less smoky) GC Candy Cane Kiss = YC Jack Frost (SBND – u like one, u like both) GC Candy Land/Cotton Candy = Blue Cotton Candy GC Candy Land Cupcake = Tootsie Rolls GC Carnival Apple/Carnival Candy Apple = BBW Cider Lane (SBND- CA/CCA is sweeter) GC Cashmere Linens = Better Homes & Gardens Soft Cashmere Amber (SBND) GC Cashmere Linens = BBW Sandalwood Coconut (SBND) GC Carrot Cake = BBW Carrot Cake (SBND) GC Champagne Bubbles/Champagne Sparkle = BBW Bright Christmas Morning = BBW Grapefruit Froze (SBND) GC Christmas Village = Peppermint Bark GC Christmas Wreath = YC Christmas Eve = Craft Store (CW less sweet w/ more cinnamon) GC Choco Puffs / GC Crazy Choco Circles = Cocoa Puffs Cereal GC Chocolate Swirl Bread = GC Homemade Brownies (SBND) GC Christmas Magic = "what the North Pole smells like" GC Christmas Tree Brownies = Hershey Park Chocolate World GC Cinnamon Sugar Swirl = Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal GC Cinnamon Sugar Vanilla = Snickerdoodle Cookies GC Cocoa Crisps = Cookie Crisp Cereal GC Coconut = GC Soothing Coconut (SBND – SC is less sweet) GC Coconut Saunawood = Body Butter GC Colorful Leaves =- Scentsy Baked Apple Pie (similar) GC Come, We Fly = Fruit Loops Cereal = Frutiy Pebbles Cereal GC Cookies & Milk = Chips Ahoy = Betty Crocker Cream Cheese Frosting GC Cosmic Brownies/Homemade Brownies/Warm Fudge Cupcake = Hershey's Chapstick = Hershey Park's Chocolate Candle GC Cozy Halloween Night = GC Campfire Marshmallow (SBND) GC Cozy Kitten = BBW Little Black Party Dress (similar but NOT a dupe - CK has citrus twist) GC Cozy Home = YC Autumn Gathering GC Cozy With You = Philosophy Fresh Cream Perfume GC Creepy Critters/Broom Squad/*Marshmallows = BBW Marshmallow Fireside/Smoky Vanilla (SBND - CC/BS more smoky) GC Cuddle Up Hygee / Demark = BBW Violet Sandalwood Eucalyptus / Inspire (similar) GC Cupid's Cocktail = Les Framboises & Cotton Candy GC Dark Cherry Merlot = BBW Black Cherry Merlot (SBND – DCM deeper/richer cherry scent) GC Day in the Sun = BBW Suntan = BBW In the Sun = Bobbi Brown Beach = Coppertone GC Drenched Coconut = Suntan Lotion GC Drenched Coconut = YC Black Coconut (SBND - if u like one u will like the other) GC Dutch Stroopwafels = Vanilla Wafer Cookies & Waffle Cones GC Eggnog Icing = GC Oatmeal Creme Pies (SBND -EI missing oat note) GC Emerald Sea Glass = "Tropical Waters & Aloe Vera" (according to gc reviewer) GC Espresso Cake Pop = Oreo Java Chip Cookies GC Eucalyptus Mist/Eucalyptus Rain Drops = Spa fragrance = Austrailian Outback GC Eucalyptus Rain Drops/Eucalyptus Mist = BBW Dancing in the Rain (ERD more natural smelling) GC Eucalyptus Rain Drops = Acqua di Gioia Perfume = Armani Code Turquoise Pefume (SBND) GC Exhilerating Pineapple = Dole Whip/Dole Plantation in Hawaii/Fresh Cut/Sliced Pineapple GC Fig & Citrus/heal = Unisex Cologne Vibes GC Forest = Christmas Pine Trees, Germany, Hiking in NY, Maine, the Pacific North West GC Forever Bewitching = GC Apple Caramel Toffee (SBND - many of the same notes) GC Frozen Waters/Iceland = BBW Frozen Lake (similar) GC Fruity Cereal Fun = GC Silly Tricks = Trix Cereal GC Fruity Hoops = Fruit Loops Cereal GC Fudge Rounds = Hot Cocoa GC Full Moon = GC Guilty Pumpkin = Pumpkin Breakfast Waffles GC Funny Bunny = BBW Sunset Glow (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Ghost Treats = BBW Pumpkin Peanut Brittle (?) GC Ghostly Goo = Sprite Soda + Fruity Pebbles GC Girl's Night Out = Debbie Gibson Electric Youth Perfume GC Glitter & Gold = Frankincense/Olibanum/Frankincens & Myrrh GC Grace = Viktor Flowerbomb GC Green Grass & Apple = BBW Garden Sage & Apple = YC Green Grass GC Guilty = BBW Mahogany Teakwood (SBND - like a combo of MT & Flannel) GC Guilty Pumpkin = BBW Pumpkin Pecan Waffles (SBND - GP has a slight popcorn-like note) GC Holiday Embers = BBW Fireside (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Honeysuckle & Green Apple = Suave Green Apple Kids Shampoo GC Honolulu Ice Cream = Dole Whip GC Ivory Pumpkin = BBW White Pumpkin (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Jingle Bells = BBW Unicorn Sprinkles (?) GC Juicy Pear = VS Pear Glace GC Jungle Pebbles = Fruity Pebbles Cereal GC Key Lime = BBW Coconut Lime Verbena = BBW Island Margarita = YC Cilantro Lime (SBND) GC Key Lime Cake Pop = Fruity Pebbles Cereal = Fruit Loops Cereal GC Key Lime Gelato = GC Lemon Vanilla Cake Batter (almost a dupe- sub lime for lemon) GC Kinda Cozy = GC The Snuggle Is Real (similar scent notes- could be a dupe) GC Lakehouse Retreat = BBW Lavender Woods (similar - they could be cousins) GC Lakeside Breeze = GC Barefoot in the Grass (similar but sub wet for earthy) GC Lakeside Leaves = Avon Skin So Soft = Boston in Autumn/Early Fall in Colorado GC Lavender Sugar = Sweet Rosemary Vanilla (LS more "luxurious") GC Lavender Twilight = Blueberry Cream (SBND?-more blueberry than lavender) GC Lavender Vanilla = BBW Lavender Marshmallow (SBND - according to gc reivewer) GC Lavender Vanilla = YC Lavender Vanilla (YCLV discontinued - SBND good substitute) GC Let's Stay Home = BBW Mahogany Coconut (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Love Letters =YC Salt Mist Peony = VS Love Spell (?) (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Lost at Sea = Disney World Hotel Rooms+ GC Lucky Marshmallows/Marshmallow Happiness = Lucky Charms Cereal GC Lush Getaway = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (LG is like MF with a summertime twist) GC Magical World of Candy = Tootsie Rolls GC Maple Syrup = Vermont Sugar Shack:-) GC Marshmallow Snow Cream = Banana Pudding/Banana Cream Pie (?) GC Marshmallow Sugar = GC Marshmallow Snow Cream (same unlisted banana cream note) GC Melon Picnic = BBW Cucumber Melon (?) GC Midnight Kiss = BBW Dark Kiss (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Mr. Mint = Butter Mints/Peppermint Ice Cream/Peppermint Vanilla Frosting GC My Wish = BBW Endless Weekend (similar but NOT a dupe) GC My Wish = Sol de Janeiro's Bum Bum Cream GC North Pole Magic = Scentsy My Dear Watson (similar) GC Oahu Citrus = BBW Sun-Washed Citrus = Capri Blue Volcano (SBND) GC Old Fashioned Cinnamon = GC Ivory Pumpkin (SBND) GC Orange Blossom = Redlands, CA (Orange Grove capital of the USA), Lakeland, FL GC Papaya Paradise = Disney's Art of Animation Hotel Lobby (SBND) GC Paradise Tea = Peach Iced Tea GC Peanut Butter Crisps = GC Peanut Butter Sugar (similar) = Peanut Butter Puffs Cereal GC Pear & Hazelnut Crepe = Nutella GC Peppermint = Candy Canes GC Peppermint Mocha Milkshake = YC Peppermint Cocoa = Starbucks Peppermint Mocha GC Pile of Leaves = BBW Sweater Weather (body care?) GC Pineapple Cake Pop = BBW Pineapple Crumb Cake (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Pink Berry Crisps = Crunch Berry Cereal = Frankenberry Cereal = Strawberry Milk GC Pink Mousse Milkshake = Voluspa Rose Petal Ice Cream GC Pink Sugar Cookie = Jo Malone Pink Macaroons GC Poison Apple = GC Carnival Apple (SBND - have 1 probably don't need the other) GC Poison Cupcake = Pillsbury Chocolate Frosting GC Pumpkin Butter Brittle = GC Butter Brittle = GC Ghost Treats (SBND - share many notes) GC Pumpkin Cider Donut = Home Interior Pumpkin Medley GC Pumpkin Pie = BBW Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin (similar?) GC Pumpkin Patch = Candleberry Friendship Tea (similar) GC Pumpkin Sugar Cookie = GC Sugared Snickerdoodle GC Rainbow Sugar/Rainbow Candied Sugar = Skittles GC Red, White & Blue = Bomb Pop GC Salem Forest = GC Into the Woods (SBND - they share 3/4 fragrance notes) GC Scarlet Apple = BBW Farmstead Apple = BBW Honey Crisp Apple (SBND) GC Silly Tricks = GC Fruity Cereal Fun = BBW Blueberry Sugar (similar) = Trix Cereal GC Snowball Fight = Endless Weekend (?) GC Snowball Fight = GC Rainbow Sugar (?) (RS has more spun sugar notes) GC Snow Covered Apple = BBW Winter Candy Apple (?) GC Snuggle With Me = BBW Flannel (similar but SWM is more sweet/less cologne) GC Soothing Rain = BBW Eucalyptus Rain (similar but NOT a dupe) = Men's Soap/Cologne GC Soothing Rain = BBW Crisp Morning Air (similar but NOT a dupe- could be cousins) GC Southern Gardens = BBW Flower Shop = YC Garden Hideaway (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Southern Gentleman = Rip Wheeler from Yellowstone GC Splish Splash = YC Coastal Living (YC has added salt note/SS is more sweet & fruity) GC Staying Home = BBW Vanilla Patchouli (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Staying Home = GC Autumn Romance/Perfect Day (SH has a more cozy, woodsy feel) GC Stories By The Campfire = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (SBND – SBTC has more amber note) GC Stories By The Campfire = GC Bedtime Stories (SBND) GC Strawberry Cake Pop = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake (SCP light w/ less fruit more vanilla) GC Strawberry Cake Pop = Bonne Belle Strawberry Lipsmackers (SCP has muddled waxiness) GC Strawberry Jam = Strawberry Shortcake Dolls GC Strawberry Pound Cake = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake (similar) GC Strawberry Sponge Cake = GC Pink Bunny Cupcake (similar but SSC has + lemon note) GC Sugar Cookie Milkshake = "A 70's Diner" GC Sugared Apple Tart = BBW Sweater Weather (apple cologne/might be batch variations?) GC Sugared Sands = Hemp Seed Skinny Dip Lotion = Victoria's Secret PINK Warm & Cozy Spray GC Sugared Shortbread / Scotland = BBW Sugared Shortbread = Walkers Scottish Cookies GC Sugared Snickerdoodle = BBW Cinnamon Caramel Swirl (silmar) GC Sugared Snowballs = BBW Coconut Cream Pie (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Suit & Tie = BBW Mahogany Teakwood = Kringle Candle Gray (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Summer Slices = GC Volcanic Sunrise = Fruit Cocktail/Fruit Punch (VS has more citrus in it) GC Sunflower Cottage = YC Sunflower (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Sunlit Sands = BBW Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit = GC Island Bliss (SBND) GC Sunlit Woods = Baby Powder (?) GC Sweet Petals = Sweet Pea GC Sweet Pine & Snowfalls = BBW Moonlit Path (?) / Avon Skin-So-Soft at Christmas GC Teakwood = GC Burlwood & Oak (SBND) GC Teakwood Merlot = GC White Woods & Apple (SBND - according to 1 gc reviewer) GC Throne of Lies = Calvin Klein Truth Perfume GC Toasty Pumpkin Toddy = BBW Pumpkin French Toast (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Tree Cutting = "Christmas in Maine" GC Trick or Treat = "like apple pie & s'mores had a baby". GC Turkish Coffee/Turkey = BBW Paris Cafe (similar but TC is sweeter and lighter) GC Vanilla & Rose Petals/Comfort/Gentle Touch = BBW Rose Vanilla/Love (not quite a dupe) GC Vanilla Bean = BBW Vanilla Bean V.1 (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Vanilla Bean Cake Pop = BBW Vanilla Bean Noel (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Vanilla Fluff = GC Marshmallow Sugar (SBND) GC Vanilla Sands = Victoria's Secret Pink Coco Vanilla (SBND) GC Vanilla Snow Angels = GC Frozen in Time (similar frag notes: vanilla, peppermint, woods) GC Vanilla Snowman/White Chocolate Buttercream = White Chocolate Mocha Hot Chocolate GC Village Pumpkin Festival = BBW Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin (VPF apple > cinnamon) GC Warm Kiss = BBW Wild Madagascar Vanilla (?) GC Watermelon Lemonade / Melon Lemonade = Watermelon Jolly Rancher GC White Christmas Cake = Grandma's Sour Cream Coconut Cake GC White Coral = BBW Pink Chiffon (?) GC Winter Splendor = BBW The Perfect Christmas GC Warm & Welcome = BBW Beach Nights (similar but W&W has sandalwood note) GC Warm & Welcome = BBW Vanilla Snowflake + BBW Warm Vanilla Sugar (combo of two) GC Warm & Welcome = GC Black Cat (similar- could be cousins) GC Welcome Home = GC Cozy Kitten (similar - if you like CK you'll like WH) GC White Pine Lake = Soarin Over California Disney Land Ride GC White Pine Lake = GC Sweet Pine & Snowflakes (could be cousins-similar fragrance notes) GC White Water Springs = Replica Beach Walk Perfume (minty citrus -WWS is less sweet) GC Winter Splendor = BBW Winter (SBND - according to 2 gc reviewers) GC Winter Whisper = GC Frozen in Time (similar fragrance notes: peppermint, citrus, woods) GC With Love = Victoria Secret Angel Perfume (similar according to a goosecreek reviewer) Dupes w/ a Twist: Guilty Pumpkin = French Toast / Maple French Toast + Ivory Pumpkin Pink Snowscape = BBW Champagne Toast + VS Love Spell (as described by a GC review) Winter Splendor = This is Christmas + Holiday Embers + mint Scent Family/Sister/Cousin Scents: ⦁ Apple Caramel Toffee/Pray = Forever Bewitching/Mary = Sugared Apple Tart/Poland ⦁ Apple Cider = Small Batch Apple Cider ⦁ Apple Gathering = Autumn Walk ⦁ Arctic Pine = First Fall Frost = Forest Pine Trees/Throne of Lies = Snowy Branches ⦁ Autumn Sunlight = Finally Fall (clove, cinnamon, earthy cousins) ⦁ Biking Trail = White Water Springs (BT is Earth, WWS is water spa cousins) ⦁ Black Cherry = Dark Cherry Merlot (BC sweeter +cherry/DCM richer +merlot) Boardwalk Candy/King Kandy = Cotton Candy = Forbidden Elixer (cotton candy/sour candy/sugary fruity scent cousins) ⦁ Boardwalk Mahogany = Boathouse = Coconut Beachwood (teakwood coconut beach bros) ⦁ Boy Tears/Late Night = Fresh Shave = Just Showered = Button Up = California Coast ⦁ Boy Tears/Late Night = Salt Water Orchid (watery citrus floral cousins- SWO female) ⦁ Broom Squad/Creepy Critters/*Marshmallows = Campfire Marshmallow = Marshmallow Monsters/Spooky Buddies ⦁ Butter Brittle/Gramma Nut/Yum = Ghost Treats = Pumpkin Butter Brittle ⦁ Butter Pecan Ice Cream = Buttered Waffle Ice Cream ⦁ Cabin Getaway = Cabin In The Woods (CG is CITW summertime brother) ⦁ Campfire Cuddle = Calm & Cozy = Cozy With You = Kinda Cozy = The Snuggle Is Real (cozy dupes/cousins) ⦁ Candied Easter Eggs = Candy Basket = Jelly Beans/Marshmallow Macaroon/France (fruity jelly belly candy family) ⦁ Candied Valentine Cookies = Velvet Santa Cookies = Pink Sugar Cookies (cookie, raspberry/cherry, vanilla icing sister scents) ⦁ Candy Bag = Hallow's Eve/Trick or Treat ⦁ Caramel Pecan Pie/Caramel Butter = North Pole Bakery (warm & sweet + bakery notes) ⦁ Care-A-Lot Castle = Care Bears: Share = Rainbow Candied Sugar/Rainbow Sugar ⦁ Carrot Cake/Carrot Cake Pop/Fall Party Cakes = Gingerbread Milkshake ⦁ Candied Valentine Cookies = Cookie Crumbles = Velvet Santa Cookies ⦁ Canteen Hot Cocoa = Easter Bunny /Melt My Heart ⦁ Cherry Pie/Gather = Homemade Cherry Pie = Mrs. Rabbit's Cherry Pie (cherry pie twinsies) ⦁ Chilly Creek Water/Chilly Rain Showers = White Water Springs (water/rain, citrus/grapefruit/eucalyptus bros) ⦁ Christmas Cakes/Christmas Tree Cakes/Vanilla Birthday Cake/Vanilla Bean Cake Pop/Warm Vanilla Cake = Baking a Cake/Be Still/Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake/Zebra Cakes ⦁ Cider & Sweaters = This is Autumn = Apple Pies & Hayrides = Fall Festival = Rustic Leaves (apple/spices/leaves family) ⦁ Cinnamon Sugar Ice Cream/Cinnamon Sugar/Honey Buns/Sugar Cookie Snack/White Icing ⦁ Clementine Sunrise = Papaya Leaf & Bamboo ⦁ Cold Water Cove = White Water Springs (waters/rain/air, salt/ocean, floral cousins) ⦁ Cookie Crumbles = Velvet Santa Cookie ⦁ Cosmic Brownies/Homemade Brownies/Warm Fudge Cupcake = Chocolate Chip Cookies = Poison Cupcake ⦁ Cinnamon Roll = Cinnamon Sugar Swirl = Cookie Butter Snowball ⦁ Eggnog Icing = Pumpkin Pound Cake = Vanilla Pumpkin Waffle (PPC is sweeter due to vanilla glaze note/EI creamier/VPW more bakery ⦁ Exhilarating Pineapple = Honolulu Ice Cream (dole whip sisters) ⦁ Emerald Sea Glass = Green Sea Grass (scent cousing according to gc reviewer) ⦁ Everything Fall = Pumpkin Gnocchi/Switzerland (PG is EF + bakery notes) = Lovely Leaves = My First Autumn ⦁ First Autumn Frost = White Pine Lake (WPL is FAF summertime sister) ⦁ Gingerbread Caramel Mousse = Gingerbread Milkshake (ginger/vanilla/caramel sibs) ⦁ Jasmine Cabana = With Love = Blooms/Bloom = Jasmine Fern (lily/jasmine woodsy cousins) ⦁ Lakeside Leaves = Sweet Pine & Snowflakes skin so soft sibs (LL is summer, SP&S is winter) ⦁ Lickable Wallpaper = Melon Picnic = Watermelon Sugar Icy Pop (might be dupes/twinsies) ⦁ Macintosh Apple = Scarlet Apple (fresh cut apples/fresh pressed cider sisters) ⦁ Midnghit Cookie Craving = Ghost Stories = Eggnog Icing ⦁ Our Family Kitchen = Sugared Pralines/Family = Caramel Butter/Caramel Pecan Pie ⦁ Peach Cobbler Donut/Peach Pecan Waffles = Pumpkin Breakfast Waffles (fall waffle+pecan+fruit cousins) ⦁ Peanut Butter Crisps = S'mores Skillet Cookie = Son of a Nutcracker ⦁ Peppermint Candy Cookie = Peppermint Mocha Milkshake ⦁ Pink Mousse Milkshake = Rose Petal Icing (BBW PPTC sisters) ⦁ Pumpkin Cupcake/Pumpkin Delights = Ivory Pumpkin/White Pumpkin ⦁ Seaside Mango = Tiki Party (mango, coconut, melon cousins) ⦁ This is Christmas = Winter Splendor (christmas tree + cinnamon siblings) ⦁ Vanilla Snowman/White Chocolate Buttercream + Irish Cream Swirl = Sweet Tiramisu/Italy = Hot Cocoa w/ splash of coffee/espresso White Water Springs = Biking Trail = Cold Water Cove (fresh & clean watery spa cousins) Pair This: Angel Food Cake + Exhilarating Pineapple = “light summertime dessert” Blueberry Jam + Maple Butter = "perfect blueberry pancake smell". Brew Potion + Haunted Forest = Halloween Enhanced Christmas Villiage + Snow Covered Trees "Christmas Day combo" Drenched Daffodils + Lilac Garden Emerald Sea Glass + Willow Tree Lane Frosted Cranberries + Gold & Glitter = "intoxicating combo" Forbidden Elixer + Poison Apple = "Super Halloween goodness" Key Lime Gelato + Soothing Coconut = amazing! Lavender de France + Bath Time / Eucalyptus Mint = “full bathtime experience” Peach Cobbler Donut/Peach Pecan Waffles + Vanilla Pumpkin Waffle Peanut Butter Vanilla Cupcake + Strawberry Jam (perfect PB&J combo) Pumpkin Pound Cake + Sugar Cookie Dough (yummy pairing!) Warm Spring Breeze + Cool Rain Drops (“open the windows after a storm”) Warm Vanilla Woods/Broom Squad/Creepy Critters + Oud Wild Berry & Waffles + Coffee House = Breakfast anyone?
0 Comments
It's been 4 years since I started Smellthis.net. Square/Weebly, my webhosting service just DOUBLED their monthly fee.
Please consider DONATING via PAYPAL or DONATING VIA SQUARE/WEEBLY For Video Reviews, vist The Candle Queen Youtube Channel Please like, share, and subscribe! *If you appreciate my DUPES lists, a donation will help me keep making them. It takes a lot of time & effort to compile these lists. I do all this because I know I would use a site like this. I figured, why not make it? There must be more people like me out there somewhere. Maybe they're looking for the perfect candles? A discontinued favorite candle? I hope whatever you came here for, you find it. **Post any requests to deep dive for a certain dupe (or if u know of one i haven't posted) by leaving a comment here or on my Dupes & Repackages Page. This site wouldn't be possible without the stellar reviews, suggestions, and DONATIONS from people like YOU -thank you for all your help! ~ The Candle Queen 💛 The 2023 BATH & BODY WORKS DUPES & REPACKAGES list Here it is - Just in time for the Bath & Body Works Summer SAS! I meant to get this out when the sale first started but I kept checking reviews and updating. Finally, I decided, for now this is good enough. This covers winter, spring. and the first half of summer's BBW scents. I hope this helps you find some of your favorites - and if anyone knows any dupes for MY favorite candles, Bath & Body Works Salt Water Taffy, and Yankee Candle's Black Coconut, you are my hero forever! Please feel free to add to the list. You just might make someone's day. 😄 I DO THIS OUT OF LOVE 💗 Please Consider DONATING! The BATH & BODY WORKS DUPES & REPACKAGES Blog **** PLEASE DO NOT REPOST OR SELL THIS LIST WITHOUT MY EXPLICIT PERMISSION. IT TAKES ME MONTHS, AND IN SOME CASES YEARS TO COMPILE ALL THIS DATA, AS WELL AS TRACK DOWN DUPES FOR THE CANDLE KINGDOM. I HATE HAVING TO POST THIS, BUT SOME PEOPLE ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THE FACT I'VE POSTED INFO FOR FREE. THEY ARE LITERALLY COPYING, PASTING, AND MAKING MONEY OFF MY HARD WORK. YOU ARE WELCOME TO USE THIS INFORMATION RECREATIONALLY, BUT PLEASE LINK BACK TO SMELLTHIS.NET AND GIVE CREDIT TO THE CANDLE QUEEN. THAT'S ALL I ASK ******
I DO THIS OUT OF LOVE 💗 Dupes: GC Amazing Grace = GC Grace GC Autumn Romance = GC Perfect Day GC Balsam Fir = BBW Fresh Balsam GC Blessed Day = YC Apple Pumpkin GC Boardwalk Mahogany = BBW Mahogany Coconut GC Blueberry Pancakes = BBW Blueberry Maple Pancakes GC Breezy Tulips = YC Tulips GC Broom Squad = GC Creepy Critters GC Butter Brittle = BBW Pumpkin Peanut Brittle GC Button-Up = GC Flannel GC Campfire Marshmallow = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (CM is more sweet/less smoky) GC Candy Cottage = BBW Pink Fairy Gumdrop GC Caramel Apple Lane / GC Caramel Applewood = BBW Cider Lane GC Champagne Bubbles = GC Champagne Sparkle = BBW Champagne Toast GC Cherry Cobbler = BBW Sugared Cherry Crisp GC Choco Puffs = GC Crazy Choco Circles GC Cinnamon Sugar Swirl = BBW Cinnamon Spriced Vanilla/ BBW Cinnamon Sugar Donut GC Citrus & Ginger = BBW Orange Ginger / energy GC Coconut & Sandalwood / Awaken = GC Coconut Sandalwood / Peaceful GC Cookie Monster = GC Bunny Cookie GC Cool Harvest Morning = BBW Autumn GC Crunchy Leaves = BBW Leaves GC Dutch Stroopwafels = GC Stroopwafels / Netherlands GC Eucalyptus & Mint = BBW Eucalyptus Spearmint = BBW Eucalyptus Mint GC Fireplace = BBW Fireside GC Fresh Baked Bread / Germany = BBW French Baugette GC Fruity Cereal Fun = GC Silly Tricks GC Jelly Beans = GC Marshmallow Macaroons / France GC Key Lime Cake Pop = BBW Key Lime Pie = BBW Marshmallow Cereal Bar GC Lavender Vanilla = Lush Sleepy GC Love Letters = YC Blush Bouquet GC Marshmallow Happiness = GC Lucky Marshmallows GC Marshmallow Macaroon/France = GC Jelly Beans GC Marshmallow Monsters = GC Spooky Buddies GC Marshmallows = BBW Marshmallow Fireside GC Midnight Berry = BBW Vampire Blood GC North Pole Magic = BBW In the Stars GC Old Time Lemonade = GC Limencello = YC Country Lemonade GC Papaya Paradise = BBW Island Papaya GC Penguin Cookies & Cream = BBW Marble Chocolate Cupcake GC Peppermint Clouds = GC Peppermint Whip GC Perfect Day = GC Autumn Romance GC Picnic Blanket = YC Warm Luxe Cashmere GC Pile of Leaves = BBW Sweater Weather GC Pink Beach = YC Pink Sands GC Poison Berry Potion = GC Boo Berry Potion GC Pumpkin Breakfast Waffles = BBW Pumpkin Pecan Waffles GC Red White & Blue = BBW Firecracker Pop GC Rose Petal Icing = BBW Pink Petal Tea Cake GC Sour Candy Martini = GC Franken Fizz GC Strawberry Sponge Cake = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake GC Summer Moon = YC Midsummer's Night GC This is Christmas = BBW The Perfect Christmas GC Tree Cutting = BBW Sweater Weather GC Tree Farm = YC Christmas Eve GC Under a Spell = VS Love Spell GC Vanilla Sands = Scentsy Vanilla Waves (VS is softer) GC Village Pumpkin Festival = BBW Apple Pumpkin = YC Apple Pumpkin GC Watermelon Lemonade = GC Melon Lemonade GC Whipped Vanilla Dreams = BBW Whipped Vanilla Chiffon GC Witch's Cauldron = YC Witches Brew Dupes: Close/Unconfirmed GC Beautiful Creatures* = GC Sugar Plum Kiss* (nearly identicle fragrance notes) GC Bergamot Mist = YC Midsummers Night (BM is lighter) GC Brew Potion* = GC Witches Cauldron * (multiple SPECIFIC fragrance notes) GC Christmas Cookies = GC Sugar Cookie Milkshake (share most fragrance notes) GC Coffee House* = GC Coffee Shop = GC Turkish Coffee/Turkey GC Colorful Leaves = BBW The Perfect Autumn (CL weaker throw) GC Island Bliss* = KC Fiji* GC Peppermint Clouds/ Peppermint Whip = BBW Twisted Peppermint ( no eucalyptus note) GC Pumpkin Sugar Cookie* = BBW Pumpkin Snickerdoodle* GC Sage Leaf & Citrus = YC Citrus & Sage (SL&C stronger w/ more sage/mint tea scent) GC Sunday Drive = BBW Cactus Blossom (SD has added raspberry note) GC Sugar Cookie* = GC Sugar Cookie Dough* GC Sugared Donut * = BBW Cinnamon Caramel Swirl* (both smell like fried ice cream) GC Vanilla Tobacco & Amber* = GC Vanilla Tobacco* (repackage or nearly identical) Smells like.... GC Apple Pumpkin = GC Village Pumpkin Festival (SBND) GC Apple Stacks = Kellogs Apple Jacks Cereal GC Autumn Apple = Baked apples/Applesauce GC Autumn Wreath = GC Colorful Leaves (SBND- CL has more leaves/wood smell) GC Autumn Romance = GC Perfect Day = VS Love Spell GC Autumn Walk = Gold Canyon Autumn Walk GC Baked Bread = BBW French Baugette GC Banana Marshmallow Ice Cream = Banana Moon Pies GC Bergamot Mist = BBW Bergamot Woods (SBND) GC Black Cat = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (SBND-BC lighter/sweeter/more musk) GC Black Pepper = Trapps Black Pepper = YC Candlelit Cabin (BP more cologne/peppery) GC Blessed Day = BBW Leaves (SBND) GC Brew Potion = GC Haunted Forest (SBND) GC Brew Potion = Theirry Mugler Angel Perfume GC Broom Squad/Creepy Critters = GC Campfire Marshmallow = BBW Marshmallow Fireside GC Button Up = Ralph Lauren Polo GC Candy Land Cupcake = Tootsie Rolls GC Carnival Apple = BBW Cider Lane (SBND- CA is sweeter) GC Cashmere Linens = Better Homes & Gardens Soft Cashmere Amber (SBND) GC Cashmere Linens = BBW Sandalwood Coconut (SBND) GC Carrot Cake = BBW Carrot Cake (SBND) GC Christmas Village = Peppermint Bark GC Christmas Wreath = YC Christmas Eve = Craft Store (CW less sweet w/ more cinnamon) GC Choco Puffs / GC Crazy Choco Circles = Cocoa Puffs Cereal GC Chocolate Swirl Bread = GC Homemade Brownies (SBND) GC Cinnamon Sugar Swirl = Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal GC Cocoa Crisps = Cookie Crisp Cereal GC Coconut Saunawood = Body Butter GC Colorful Leaves =- Scentsy Baked Apple Pie (similar) Come, We Fly = Fruit Loops Cereal = Frutiy Pebbles Cereal GC Cookies & Milk = Chips Ahoy = Betty Crocker Cream Cheese Frosting GC Cozy Halloween Night = GC Campfire Marshmallow (SBND) GC Cozy Kitten = BBW Little Black Party Dress (similar but NOT a dupe - CK has citrus twist) GC Cozy Home = YC Autumn Gathering GC Cozy With You = Philosophy Fresh Cream Perfume GC Creepy Critters/Broom Squad = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (SBND - CC/BS more smoky) GC Cuddle Up Hygee / Demark = BBW Violet Sandalwood Eucalyptus / Inspire (similar) GC Cupid's Cocktail = Les Framboises & Cotton Candy GC Dark Cherry Merlot = BBW Black Cherry Merlot GC Day in the Sun = BBW Suntan = BBW In the Sun = Bobbi Brown Beach = Coppertone GC Dazzeling Popcorn = BBW Summer Boardwalk (redditer says dupe- need confirmation) GC Drenched Coconut = Suntan Lotion GC Drenched Coconut = YC Black Coconut (SBND - if u like one u will like the other) GC Dutch Stroopwafels = Vanilla Wafer Cookies & Waffle Cones GC Espresso Cake Pop = Oreo Java Chip Cookies GC Eucalyptus Rain Drops = BBW Dancing in the Rain (ERD is more natural smelling) GC Eucalyptus Rain Drops = Acqua di Gioia Perfume = Armani Code Turquoise Pefume (SBND) GC Forest = Christmas Pine Trees, NY & Maine forests GC Forever Bewitching = GC Apple Caramel Toffee (SBND - many of the same notes) GC Frozen Waters/Iceland = BBW Frozen Lake (similar) GC Fruity Cereal Fun = GC Silly Tricks = Trix Cereal GC Fruity Hoops = Fruit Loops Cereal GC Full Moon = GC Guilty Pumpkin = Pumpkin Breakfast Waffles GC Funny Bunny = BBW Sunset Glow (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Ghost Treats = BBW Pumpkin Peanut Brittle (?) GC Ghostly Goo = Sprite Soda + Fruity Pebbles GC Girl's Night Out = Debbie Gibson Electric Youth Perfume GC Glitter & Gold = Frankincense/Olibanum/Frankincens & Myrrh GC Grace = Viktor Flowerbomb GC Green Grass & Apple = BBW Garden Sage & Apple = YC Green Grass GC Guilty Pumpkin = BBW Pumpkin Pecan Waffles (SBND - GP has a slight popcorn-like note) GC Holiday Embers = BBW Fireside (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Ivory Pumpkin = BBW White Pumpkin (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Jingle Bells = BBW Unicorn Sprinkles (?) GC Juicy Pear = VS Pear Glace GC Jungle Pebbles = Fruity Pebbles Cereal GC Key Lime = BBW Coconut Lime Verbena (SBND) GC Key Lime Cake Pop = Fruity Pebbles Cereal = Fruit Loops Cereal GC Key Lime Gelato = GC Lemon Vanilla Cake Batter (almost a dupe- sub lime for lemon) GC Lakehouse Retreat = BBW Lavender Woods (similar - they could be cousins) GC Lakeside Breeze = GC Barefoot in the Grass (similar but sub wet for earthy) GC Lavender Sugar = Sweet Rosemary Vanilla (LS more "luxurious") GC Let's Stay Home = BBW Mahogany Coconut (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Love Letters =YC Salt Mist Peony = VS Love Spell (?) (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Lucky Marshmallows/Marshmallow Happiness = Lucky Charms Cereal GC Lush Getaway = BBW Marshmallow Fireside (LG is like MF with a summertime twist) GC Marshmallow Snow Cream = banana pudding/banana cream pie (?) GC Marshmallow Sugar = GC Marshmallow Snow Cream (same unlisted banana cream note) GC Melon Picnic = BBW Cucumber Melon (?) GC Midnight Kiss = BBW Dark Kiss (similar but NOT a dupe) GC My Wish = BBW Endless Weekend (similar but NOT a dupe) GC My Wish = Sol de Janeiro's Bum Bum Cream GC North Pole Magic = Scentsy My Dear Watson (similar) GC Oahu Citrus = BBW Sun-Washed Citrus = Capri Blue Volcano (SBND) GC Orange Blossom = Redlands, CA (Orange Grove capital of the USA), Lakeland, FL GC Peanut Butter Crisps = GC Peanut Butter Sugar (similar) = Peanut Butter Puffs Cereal GC Pear & Hazelnut Crepe = Nutella GC Peppermint = Candy Canes GC Peppermint Mocha Milkshake = YC Peppermint Cocoa = Starbucks Peppermint Mocha GC Pile of Leaves = BBW Sweater Weather (body care?) GC Pineapple Cake Pop = BBW Pineapple Crumb Cake (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Pink Berry Crisps = Crunch Berry Cereal = Frankenberry Cereal = Strawberry Milk GC Pink Mousse Milkshake = Voluspa Rose Petal Ice Cream GC Pink Sugar Cookie = Jo Malone Pink Macaroons GC Poison Apple = GC Carnival Apple (SBND - have 1 probably don't need the other) GC Poison Cupcake = Pillsbury Chocolate Frosting GC Pumpkin Butter Brittle = GC Butter Brittle = GC Ghost Treats (SBND - share many notes) GC Pumpkin Cider Donut = Home Interior Pumpkin Medley GC Pumpkin Pie = BBW Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin (similar?) GC Pumpkin Patch = Candleberry Friendship Tea (similar) GC Pumpkin Sugar Cookie = GC Sugared Snickerdoodle GC Rainbow Sugar = Skittles GC Red, White & Blue = Bomb Pop GC Salem Forest = GC Into the Woods (SBND - they share 3/4 fragrance notes) GC Silly Tricks = GC Fruity Cereal Fun = BBW Blueberry Sugar (similar) = Trix Cereal GC Snowball Fight = Endless Weekend (?) GC Snowball Fight = GC Rainbow Sugar (?) (RS has more spun sugar notes) GC Snow Covered Apple = BBW Winter Candy Apple (?) GC Snuggle With Me = BBW Flannel (similar but SWM is more sweet/less cologne) GC Soothing Rain = BBW Eucalyptus Rain (similar but NOT a dupe) = Men's Soap/Cologne GC Soothing Rain = BBW Crisp Morning Air (similar but NOT a dupe- could be cousins) GC Southern Gardens = BBW Flower Shop = YC Garden Hideaway (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Splish Splash = YC Coastal Living (YC has added salt note/SS is more sweet & fruity) GC Staying Home = BBW Vanilla Patchouli (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Staying Home = GC Autumn Romance/Perfect Day (SH has a more cozy, woodsy feel) GC Strawberry Cake Pop = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake (SCP light w/ less fruit more vanilla) GC Strawberry Cake Pop = Bonne Belle Strawberry Lipsmackers (SCP has muddled waxiness) GC Strawberry Jam = Strawberry Shortcake Dolls GC Strawberry Pound Cake = BBW Strawberry Pound Cake (similar) GC Strawberry Sponge Cake = GC Pink Bunny Cupcake (similar but SSC has + lemon note) GC Sugared Apple Tart = BBW Sweater Weather (apple cologne/might be batch variations?) GC Sugared Sands = Hemp Seed Skinny Dip Lotion = Victoria's Secret PINK Warm & Cozy Spray GC Sugared Shortbread / Scotland = BBW Sugared Shortbread = Walkers Scottish Cookies GC Sugared Snickerdoodle = BBW Cinnamon Caramel Swirl (silmar) GC Sugared Snowballs = BBW Coconut Cream Pie (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Suit & Tie = BBW Mahogany Teakwood = Kringle Candle Gray (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Summer Slices = GC Volcanic Sunrise = Fruit Cocktail/Fruit Punch (VS has more citrus in it) GC Sunflower Cottage = YC Sunflower (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Sunlit Sands = BBW Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit = GC Island Bliss (SBND) GC Sunlit Woods = Baby Powder (?) GC Sweet Petals = Sweet Pea GC Sweet Pine & Snowfalls = BBW Moonlit Path (?) / Avon Skin-So-Soft at Christmas GC Toasty Pumpkin Toddy = BBW Pumpkin French Toast (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Trick or Treat = "like apple pie & s'mores had a baby". GC Turkish Coffee/Turkey = BBW Paris Cafe (similar but TC is sweeter and lighter) GC Vanilla & Rose Petals/Comfort/Gentle Touch = BBW Rose Vanilla/Love (not quite a dupe) GC Vanilla Bean = BBW Vanilla Bean V.1 (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Vanilla Bean Cake Pop = BBW Vanilla Bean Noel (similar but NOT a dupe) GC Vanilla Snow Angels = GC Frozen in Time (similar frag notes: vanilla, peppermint, woods) GC Village Pumpkin Festival = BBW Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin (VPF apple > cinnamon) GC Warm Kiss = BBW Wild Madagascar Vanilla (?) GC Watermelon Lemonade / Melon Lemonade = Watermelon Jolly Rancher GC White Coral = BBW Pink Chiffon (?) GC Winter Splendor = BBW The Perfect Christmas GC Warm & Welcome = BBW Beach Nights (similar but W&W has sandalwood note) GC Warm & Welcome = BBW Vanilla Snowflake + BBW Warm Vanilla Sugar (combo of two) GC Warm & Welcome = GC Black Cat (similar- could be cousins) GC Welcome Home = GC Cozy Kitten (similar - if you like CK you'll like WH) GC White Pine Lake = Soarin Over California Disney Land Ride GC White Pine Lake = GC Sweet Pine & Snowflakes (could be cousins-similar fragrance notes) GC White Water Springs = Replica Beach Walk Perfume (WWS is less sweet) GC Winter Whisper = GC Frozen in Time (similar fragrance notes: peppermint, citrus, woods) GC With Love = Victoria Secret Angel Perfume (similar according to a goosecreek reviewer) Dupes w/ a Twist: Guilty Pumpkin = French Toast / Maple French Toast + Ivory Pumpkin Pink Snowscape = BBW Champagne Toast + VS Love Spell (as described by a GC review) Pair This: Frosted Cranberries + Gold & Glitter = "intoxicating combo" Forbidden Elixer + Poison Apple = "Super Halloween goodness" Brew Potion + Haunted Forest = Halloween Enhanced It's been 4 years since I started Smellthis.net. Square/Weebly, my webhosting service just DOUBLED their monthly fee.
Please consider DONATING via PAYPAL or DONATING VIA SQUARE/WEEBLY For Video Reviews, vist The Candle Queen Youtube Channel Please like, share, and subscribe! *If you appreciate my DUPES lists, a donation will help me keep making them. It takes a lot of time & effort to compile these lists. I do all this because I know I would use a site like this. I figured, why not make it? There must be more people like me out there somewhere. Maybe they're looking for the perfect candles? A discontinued favorite candle? I hope whatever you came here for, you find it. **Post any requests to deep dive for a certain dupe (or if u know of one i haven't posted) by leaving a comment here or on my Dupes & Repackages Page. This site wouldn't be possible without the stellar reviews, suggestions, and DONATIONS from people like YOU -thank you for all your help! ~ The Candle Queen 💛 **** PLEASE DO NOT REPOST OR SELL THIS LIST WITHOUT MY EXPLICIT PERMISSION. IT TAKES ME MONTHS, AND IN SOME CASES YEARS TO COMPILE ALL THIS DATA, AS WELL AS TRACK DOWN DUPES FOR THE CANDLE KINGDOM. I HATE HAVING TO POST THIS, BUT SOME PEOPLE ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THE FACT I'VE POSTED INFO FOR FREE. THEY ARE LITERALLY COPYING, PASTING, AND MAKING MONEY OFF MY HARD WORK. YOU ARE WELCOME TO USE THIS INFORMATION RECREATIONALLY, BUT PLEASE LINK BACK TO SMELLTHIS.NET AND GIVE CREDIT TO THE CANDLE QUEEN. THAT'S ALL I ASK ****** I DO THIS OUT OF LOVE 💗
Beach Night Summer Marshmallow = Vanilla Bean Blueberry Sugared Donut = Santa's Blueberry Shortbread Boardwalk Taffy = Cotton Candy Clouds = Whipped Berry Meringue *Bonfire Bash = *Sweet Whiskey Bora Bora Citrus Surf = Sun-Washed Citrus Bourbon Strawberry & Vanilla = Secret Wonderland = Wild Strawberry Leaf Cherry Frost = Firecracker Pop Coco Shea Honey = Honey WIldflower Coconut = Coconut Vanilla = Exotic Coconut Coconut Cream Pie = Exotic Coconut (CCP is a lighter version of EC) Coconut Pineapple = Iced Pineapple (as close as it gets) *Confetti Cake Pop = *Christmas Cookies Confetti Daydream = Daydream Cozy Sunday Morning = Lavender Sandalwood (Wellness Collection) *Fresh Gardenia & Lime = *Gardenia & Fresh Rain Honey Wildflower = Coco Shea Honey = Sweet Almond & Honey (same honey notes) Juicy Pink Dragonfruit = Lush Pink Dragonfruit Mad About You = Moroccan Orchid & Pink Amber Sea Island Cotton = Sea Island Shore Aromatherapy Orange & Cedarwood / Calm = Aromatherapy Nighttime Tea Aromatherapy Passion Tuberose & Ylang Ylang = Aromatherapy Optimism #EASTER = Buttercream Frosting / Frosted Cupcake / Confetti Cupcake (Sparkle Everyday) Adobe Sunset = Spiced Citrus Sonoma Almond = Almond Blossom *Almond Matcha = *Lemongrass Cardamom Aloha Waikiki = Hawaiian Hibiscus Amazon Falls = Sea Grass American Boardwalk = Summer Boardwalk = Sweet Home Chicago Amethyst (Peace Potion) = Moonlit Path Amsterdam = Flower Shop = Rose Apple Cardamom = Warm Apple Pie Apple Flower = Pink Apple Punch Apple Garland = Apple Spruce = WB Christmas 2012 Aquamarine (Clarity Elixir) = Beach Sage & Mint Autumn Day = Acorn & Fig Autumn Night = Cardamom & Suede= Holly Jolly Christmas Autumn Sky = Bergamot Woods = *Sunlit Cedar = Villa Bergamot Autumn Sunshine = Golden Citrus Autumn Snow = Pinecone *Baltic Black Pearl = *Indigo Sky Banana Cabana = Tropical Banana Bangkok = Tropical Spice Barcelona = Caribbean Salsa Beach Breeze = Waikiki Beach Coconut Beachside = Sunny St. Tropaz = Suntan #2 Bergamot & Suede = Bergamot Woods = Michigan Avenue = Ocean Drive = Villa Bergamot Bergamot Waters = Holiday Sparkle Berry Pumpkin Strudel = Spiced Pumpkin Cider Berry Waffle Cone = Waffle Cone Black Teakwood = Mahogany Teakwood Black Tie = Sage & Cedar Blackberries & Basil = Blackberry Tea Leaf (nearly identical) Bloom = First Bloom = Live in Sunshine = Mother's Day 2015 Blueberry Crumble = Blueberry Glazed Donut Blueberry Lavender Lemonade = Blueberry Lavender Spritzer Blueberry Sugared Donut = Santa's Blueberry Shortbread Blushing Pink Rose Petals = Winter Rose Bora Bora = Meet Me in Tahiti Bourbon Maple = Sunkissed Maple Brazilian Blue Waters = Sea Spray = Turquoise Waters Bright Autumn Sky = Bright Winter Sky Bright Bouquet = Fresh *Spring Blue Skies*= Flirt = Mother's Day 2013 = Paris Daydream Bright Verbena Blossoms (Sunshine) = Lemon Verbena = Seaside Citrus Brown Butter Praline = French Caramel Cake = Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake = Pumpkin Spiced Cheesecake Bourbon Butterscotch = Hot Buttered Rum Cactus Lily = Velvet Tuberose Café Italia = Espresso Bar = Gourmet Espresso = Road to Kona California = Poolside = Suntan #1 Campfire Pumpkin = Pumpkin Fireside Candied Pecans = Praline Pecan = Praline Pecan Cobbler Candy Hearts = Pink Fairy Gumdrop = *Unicorn Sprinkles Capri = Freshwater & Sea Salt = Sea to Santorini Capri Citron = Pomelo Citron = Yuzu Caramel Apple = Sweet Caramel Comfort (Home) - golden apple, brown sugar, cream caramel, anjou pear, nutmeg, vanilla cream Caramel Pumpkin Swirl = Cinnamon Caramel Swirl *Cardamom & Ginger = *Lemongrass Cardamom Cardamom & Suede = Holly Jolly Christmas = Autumn Night Casablanca Lily = Easter Lily Cashmere & Oak = Winter Woods Cashmere & Sandalwood = Vanilla Sandalwood (Mountainside Suite) - vanilla, sandalwood, musk *Cereal Marshmallow Bar = *Key Lime Pie = *Rainbow Confetti Champagne Toast = You Are Loved Cheers to Capri = Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest Cherry Cheesecake = Frosted Cake Pop Cherry Frost = Firecracker Pop Chestnut & Clove = Winter Cabin Chocolate Lava Cake = Hot Fudge Sundae *Chocolate Peppermint Cream = *Mint Chocolate (OG Slatkin) Cider Lane = Warm Caramel Cider *Cinnamon Bark = *Spiced Wreath Cinnamon Pinecone = Spiced Autumn Wreath Cinnamon Sugared Donut = Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla = Glazed Cinnamon Bun Citrine (Happy Dust) = Ocean Mist & Citrus = Ocean Therapy Citrus & Sandalwood = Citron Cedarwood = Sandalwood Citrus Citrus & Spice = Holiday Pomander - citrus fruits, bay rum (bay leaves, citrus peel/oil, cloves, cinnamon, allspice in rum) leafy balsam, musk *Citrus Flower = *Coastal Sun Citrus Sugar Cookie = Frosted Biscotti - citrus frosting, maple sugar, warm cookies Coastal Morning = Ocean Mist & Citrus Coconut Pineapple = Iced Pineapple = Paradise Coconut Cotton & Eucalyptus = Eucalyptus Cotton = Frosty Air Cotton Candy Marshmallow = Strawberry Picnic = Strawberry Sorbet Cozy Cabin = Ski Lodge Cranberry Peach = Cranberry Peach Prosecco Cranberry Pumpkin = Cranberry Sugar Cookie Cranberry Woods = Sun-Drenched Vineyard Creamy Nutmeg = Winter Vanilla Latte Dance til Dawn = Mango Coconut Cooler = Tropical Tango Desert Heat = Palo Santo *Desert Rain = *Sweet Fern Dolce = Vanilla Bean Noel Den = Havana = Havana Heat = Lavender & Agarwood = Ski Den Electric Tokyo = Hearts & Flowers = Love = WB Mothers Day 2014 = Peony Petals = Pink Petals = Tokyo Petals Espresso Bar = Gourmet Espresso = Harvest Coffee= Winter Café Eucalyptus & Cotton = Frosty Air Eucalyptus Mint & Rain = Eucalyptus Mint & Waves = White Barn Summer Farmstand Apple = Heirloom Apple = Suncrisp Apple Fireside Christmas = Yuletide - firewood bundle, pine needles, crisp eucalyptus, smoked incense Fireside Pine = Golden Woods = The Original = Winter Cedar First Bloom = Fresh Blossom (Live in Sunshine) First Frost = Peppered Suede Flirt = Paris Daydream = Spring Blue Skies (Fresh) French Garden = Peach Lavender French Lavender = Lavender Linens (Relax) Fresh Coconut & Cotton = Coconut & Cotton Fresh Cut Lilac = Lilac *Fresh Mint & Coconut = *Summer Terrace Fresh Water & Sea Salt = Sea to Santorini Frosted Cranberry = Merry Christmas Garden Strawberry = Strawberry = Strawberry Patch Gelato = Raspberry Peach Macaron = Sweet Macaron Georgia Peach = Georgia Market Peach = Golden Peach Sparkle = Peach Meringue = White Peach Go With the Flow = Topaz Waters = Turquoise Waters Gold Coast = Flannel Golden Pineapple Luau = Pina Colada Smoothie Green Daisy = Green Grass = Sunlit Gardens = Sunshine& Green Daisies (Happy) Havana Heat = Leather & Sweet Tobacco (Ski Den) - fine leather, sweet tobacco, caramel Heirloom Apple = Honeycrisp Apple Heirloom Garden = Tomato Garden Holly Berry Balsam = Merry Mistletoe Homemade Cookie = Merry Cookie Honeysuckle = Honeysuckle Bouquet - sweet honeysuckle, pink peony, creamy vanilla Hot Cocoa & Cream = Easter Bunny = Hippity Hop = Ohio *Iced Coconut Milk = *White Velvet Coconut *Iced Vanilla Woods = *White Birch Island Papaya = Pineapple Mango = Papaya Sunrise Island Sands = White Sands *Jade (Healing Spell) = *Incense Lakeshore Drive = Refresh = Renew & Refresh = Seashore = The Keys Lakeside = Verbena Waters Lavender Market = Peace Lemon & Fig = Sunny Fig Lemon Drops = Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemons Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemonade Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemons Love = Electric Tokyo = Hearts & Flowers = Mothers Day 2014 = Peony Petals = Pink Petals = Tokyo Petals Mad About Madrid = Tailgate II = Texas = Tobacco Flower Mahogany Teakwood = Black Teakwood = Ocean Driftwood (2014) Malibu Citrus Glow = Peach Bellini = Sweet Peach & Nectarine Mango Cilantro = Peach Cilantro Twist *Mango Dragonfruit = *Merry Mango = Sweet Maui Mango = Tiki Dragonfruit (Chase the Sun) Mango Mai Tai = Tiki Mango Mai Tai Maple Cinnamon Pancakes = Pumpkin Caramel Latte Marble Toffee = Summer Boardwalk Market Herbs = Tuscan Herbs Marshmallow Fireside = Smoked Vanilla = Trick or Treat Marshmallow Fluff = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Merry Mistletoe = Winter Wreath Midnight Blue Citrus = Snowflakes & Citrus *Mint Chocolate II (2013) =*Peppermint Brownie North Avenue Beach = Tiki Beach Orange Cream Soda = Orange Creamsicle Pacific Coast Highway = Winter Sun Pacific Ocean Air = Sea Salt & Balsam Palm Leaves = White Palm *Papaya Sunrise = *Sunset Beach (papaya, pineapple, sugarcane Paris = Pink Champagne = Sparkling Berries & Pears *Paris Café = But First Coffee = *Café Au Lait = Campsite Coffee Passionflower = Pink Apple Punch Passionfruit Cupcake = Pineapple Crumb Cake Pineapple Mango = Sugarcane Pineapple (fresh pineapple juice, mango, vine-ripened raspberry) Pink Fairy Gumdrop = Be Mine Pink Passionfruit = Red Guava Lava = Rio Red Guava Pink Watermelon = Sugared Watermelon Pomegranate = Wild Huckleberry Poolside = Sunny St. Tropez = Suntan Poolside Daydream = Sun Soaked Sandalwood Poppy Sunshine = Wild Poppies Pumpkin Coconut = Spiced Madeline = Toasted Coconut Pumpkin Milkshake = Vanilla Snowflake Pumpkin Pie = Pumpkin Vanilla = Pumpkin Vanilla Crème Pumpkin Spice Latte = Sweet Tiramisu Renew & Refresh = Seashore = Sydney Harbor (saltwater, exhilarating eucalyptus, bamboo wood) Rainforest Gardenia = Seaside Gardenia = White Gardenia Pink Lemonade Punch (Smile) = Raspberry Citrus Swirl = Sparkling Sugarplum Salted Caramel = Salted Caramel Corn Salted White Mango (I Need Vitamin C) = Sun-Drenched Mango *Sand & Sea = *Sea Salt & Sandalwood Sandalwood & Suede = Vetiver Sandalwood Sangria Berry Fizz = Sparkling Berry Fizz Sea Grass = Snap Peas Sea Island Blossom = Sunlit Cashmere Sea Island Cotton = Sea Island Shore *Sea Spray = *Turquoise Waters Sensual Amber = Sparkling Amber Sicilian Orange = Sweet Clementine Smoked Berries & Incense = Wine Cellar Snow Fall II = Spruce Snowflakes & Cashmere = Chestnuts & Argon Sparkling Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest Strawberry Picnic = Cotton Candy Marshmallow = Strawberry Sorbet Sugared Cherry Crisp = Sweet Cherry Pie Sun-Washed Citrus = Capri Citron = Merci Beaucoup Sunlit Cashmere = Sea Island Blossom Toffee Brittle = Toasted Coconut Vanilla & Coconut = Vanilla Snowflake Vanilla Bean = Vanilla Bean Macaron = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Warm Apple Pie = Apple Cardamom White Sage & Aloe = Wild Sage & Aloe Winter Woods = NOOK Wisteria Garden = Merci Paris / Thank You (notes: creamy vanilla, rich black currant, soft jasmine) *there are varying opinions on whether or not this is a dupe. Multiple people must confirm this is a repackaged scent. These are Repackages with a twist/change- similar but not exact dupes. SISTER SCENTS/ COUSIN SCENTS Apple Flower / Pink Apple Punch = Green Apple Champagne, Green Apple Orchard, Passionflower (?), Wasabi Apple, Weekend Apple Picking Autumn Sky / Sunlit Cedar = Crisp Morning Air Autumn Night = Evening Hearth (A is EH's big brother) Banana Pumpkin Muffin = Banana Nutmeg Bread Pudding Beach Sage & Mint = Summer Terrace (minus BS&M's sharp bergamot note) Black Sands = Perfect Waves / EM & Waves = WB Summer = Eucalyptus Mint & Rain Black Tea & Rose = Golden Amber Oak Blackberry Bramble Tea = Blueberry Pumpkin Patch Blue Orchard Skies = Country Apple (similar but NOT a dupe) Blue Sage & Sandalwood = Magnificent Milan Blueberry Pumpkin Strudel = Spiced Pumpkin Cider Bourbon Butterscotch =Hot Buttered Rum Bourbon Maple = Bourbon Sea Salt Caramel Bowties & Bourbon + Ocean Mist & Citrus = Blue Bungalow Cardamom & Suede / Holly Jolly Christmas / Autumn Nights = Autumn Day Cashmere & Oak / Winter Woods = Peppercorn Celebrate = Tis the Season (minus TTS pine note) Cinnamon Caramel Swirl = Gingerbread & Caramel Coastal Oak & Sea Salt II = Orange Blossom & Driftwood = Sea Salt & Linen Coconut Mango Cooler + Champagne Toast = Tropical Tango (Dance Til Dawn) Cotton Candy Marshmallow / Strawberry Picnic / Strawberry Sorbet = Saltwater Taffy Creamy Pumpkin = White Pumpkin (same Slatkin recipe w/ less spice than WP) Dark Kiss = Little Black Party Dress (note: both are fruity, patchouli-forward sister scents) Evening Hearth = Pumpkin Hayride (similar but NOT a dupe) Farmstand Apple + Frosted Cranberry = Iced Cranapple Fresh Linen = Sun-Drenched Linen (similar but NOT a dupe) Fresh Water & Sea Salt / Sea to Santorini = Oceanside (note: FW&SS/ STS more updated/sophisticated/feminine) Frosted Cupcake + Vanilla Pumpkin Marshmallow = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Glazed Cinnamon Bun = Pumpkin Cinnamon Bun (NOT a dupe but could be fraternal twins) Go With the Flow / Topaz Waters / Turquoise Waters = Sea Spray & Beach Grass Gold Coast / Flannel = Black Forest Woods (?) Honey & Tangerine = Optimism Incense = Tobacco Flower *Island Waters = *Sunrise Lagoon Lavender Coconut / Lavender Sea = Lavender Woods Lilac Blossom + Provence Garden = Cucumber & Lily Mango Coconut Cooler + Pineapple Lychee Smoothie = Papaya Sunrise = Sunset Beach Paris / Pink Champagne / Pomegranate Prosecco Punch / Sparkling Berries & Pears = Cranberry Pear Bellini Pink Sands & Petals = Vanilla Beach Flower (PS&P is less intense & more floral) Praline Pecan & Cream = Pumpkin Pecan Waffles (minus PPW maple note) Pumpkin Milkshake = Vanilla Snowflake (PM is a creamier scent) Smoked Berries & Incense / Wine Cellar = Peppered Plum (NOT a dupe but could be twinsies) Spiced Pineapple Samba = Tropical Spice (SPS has a pineapple note) Spring + Luck = The Perfect Spring Vanilla Chai = Winter Latte
Beach Night Summer Marshmallow = Vanilla Bean Blueberry Sugared Donut = Santa's Blueberry Shortbread Boardwalk Taffy = Cotton Candy Clouds = Whipped Berry Meringue *Bonfire Bash = *Sweet Whiskey Bora Bora Citrus Surf = Sun-Washed Citrus Bourbon Strawberry & Vanilla = Secret Wonderland = Wild Strawberry Leaf Cherry Frost = Firecracker Pop Coco Shea Honey = Honey WIldflower Coconut = Coconut Vanilla = Exotic Coconut Coconut Cream Pie = Exotic Coconut (CCP is a lighter version of EC) Coconut Pineapple = Iced Pineapple (as close as it gets) *Confetti Cake Pop = *Christmas Cookies Confetti Daydream = Daydream Cozy Sunday Morning = Lavender Sandalwood (Wellness Collection) *Fresh Gardenia & Lime = *Gardenia & Fresh Rain Honey Wildflower = Coco Shea Honey = Sweet Almond & Honey (same honey notes) Juicy Pink Dragonfruit = Lush Pink Dragonfruit Mad About You = Moroccan Orchid & Pink Amber Sea Island Cotton = Sea Island Shore
Aromatherapy Orange & Cedarwood / Calm = Aromatherapy Nighttime Tea Aromatherapy Passion Tuberose & Ylang Ylang = Aromatherapy Optimism #EASTER = Buttercream Frosting / Frosted Cupcake / Confetti Cupcake (Sparkle Everyday) Adobe Sunset = Spiced Citrus Sonoma Almond = Almond Blossom *Almond Matcha = *Lemongrass Cardamom Aloha Waikiki = Hawaiian Hibiscus Amazon Falls = Sea Grass American Boardwalk = Summer Boardwalk = Sweet Home Chicago Amethyst (Peace Potion) = Moonlit Path Amsterdam = Flower Shop = Rose Apple Cardamom = Warm Apple Pie Apple Flower = Pink Apple Punch Apple Garland = Apple Spruce = WB Christmas 2012 Aquamarine (Clarity Elixir) = Beach Sage & Mint Autumn Day = Acorn & Fig Autumn Night = Cardamom & Suede= Holly Jolly Christmas Autumn Sky = Bergamot Woods = *Sunlit Cedar = Villa Bergamot Autumn Sunshine = Golden Citrus Autumn Snow = Pinecone *Baltic Black Pearl = *Indigo Sky Banana Cabana = Tropical Banana Bangkok = Tropical Spice Barcelona = Caribbean Salsa Beach Breeze = Waikiki Beach Coconut Beachside = Sunny St. Tropaz = Suntan #2 Bergamot & Suede = Bergamot Woods = Michigan Avenue = Ocean Drive = Villa Bergamot Bergamot Waters = Holiday Sparkle Berry Pumpkin Strudel = Spiced Pumpkin Cider Berry Waffle Cone = Waffle Cone Black Teakwood = Mahogany Teakwood Black Tie = Sage & Cedar Blackberries & Basil = Blackberry Tea Leaf (nearly identical) Bloom = First Bloom = Live in Sunshine = Mother's Day 2015 Blueberry Crumble = Blueberry Glazed Donut Blueberry Lavender Lemonade = Blueberry Lavender Spritzer Blueberry Sugared Donut = Santa's Blueberry Shortbread Blushing Pink Rose Petals = Winter Rose Bora Bora = Meet Me in Tahiti Bourbon Maple = Sunkissed Maple Brazilian Blue Waters = Sea Spray = Turquoise Waters Bright Autumn Sky = Bright Winter Sky Bright Bouquet = Fresh *Spring Blue Skies*= Flirt = Mother's Day 2013 = Paris Daydream Bright Verbena Blossoms (Sunshine) = Lemon Verbena = Seaside Citrus Brown Butter Praline = French Caramel Cake = Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake = Pumpkin Spiced Cheesecake Bourbon Butterscotch = Hot Buttered Rum Cactus Lily = Velvet Tuberose Café Italia = Espresso Bar = Gourmet Espresso = Road to Kona California = Poolside = Suntan #1 Campfire Pumpkin = Pumpkin Fireside Candied Pecans = Praline Pecan = Praline Pecan Cobbler Candy Hearts = Pink Fairy Gumdrop = *Unicorn Sprinkles Capri = Freshwater & Sea Salt = Sea to Santorini Capri Citron = Pomelo Citron = Yuzu Caramel Apple = Sweet Caramel Comfort (Home) - golden apple, brown sugar, cream caramel, anjou pear, nutmeg, vanilla cream Caramel Pumpkin Swirl = Cinnamon Caramel Swirl *Cardamom & Ginger = *Lemongrass Cardamom Cardamom & Suede = Holly Jolly Christmas = Autumn Night Casablanca Lily = Easter Lily Cashmere & Oak = Winter Woods Cashmere & Sandalwood = Vanilla Sandalwood (Mountainside Suite) - vanilla, sandalwood, musk *Cereal Marshmallow Bar = *Key Lime Pie = *Rainbow Confetti Champagne Toast = You Are Loved Cheers to Capri = Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest Cherry Cheesecake = Frosted Cake Pop Cherry Frost = Firecracker Pop Chestnut & Clove = Winter Cabin Chocolate Lava Cake = Hot Fudge Sundae *Chocolate Peppermint Cream = *Mint Chocolate (OG Slatkin) Cider Lane = Warm Caramel Cider *Cinnamon Bark = *Spiced Wreath Cinnamon Pinecone = Spiced Autumn Wreath Cinnamon Sugared Donut = Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla = Glazed Cinnamon Bun Citrine (Happy Dust) = Ocean Mist & Citrus = Ocean Therapy Citrus & Sandalwood = Citron Cedarwood = Sandalwood Citrus Citrus & Spice = Holiday Pomander - citrus fruits, bay rum (bay leaves, citrus peel/oil, cloves, cinnamon, allspice in rum) leafy balsam, musk *Citrus Flower = *Coastal Sun Citrus Sugar Cookie = Frosted Biscotti - citrus frosting, maple sugar, warm cookies Coastal Morning = Ocean Mist & Citrus Coconut Pineapple = Iced Pineapple = Paradise Coconut Cotton & Eucalyptus = Eucalyptus Cotton = Frosty Air Cotton Candy Marshmallow = Strawberry Picnic = Strawberry Sorbet Cozy Cabin = Ski Lodge Cranberry Peach = Cranberry Peach Prosecco Cranberry Pumpkin = Cranberry Sugar Cookie Cranberry Woods = Sun-Drenched Vineyard Creamy Nutmeg = Winter Vanilla Latte Dance til Dawn = Mango Coconut Cooler = Tropical Tango Desert Heat = Palo Santo *Desert Rain = *Sweet Fern Dolce = Vanilla Bean Noel Den = Havana = Havana Heat = Lavender & Agarwood = Ski Den Electric Tokyo = Hearts & Flowers = Love = WB Mothers Day 2014 = Peony Petals = Pink Petals = Tokyo Petals Espresso Bar = Gourmet Espresso = Harvest Coffee= Winter Café Eucalyptus & Cotton = Frosty Air Eucalyptus Mint & Rain = Eucalyptus Mint & Waves = White Barn Summer Farmstand Apple = Heirloom Apple = Suncrisp Apple Fireside Christmas = Yuletide - firewood bundle, pine needles, crisp eucalyptus, smoked incense Fireside Pine = Golden Woods = The Original = Winter Cedar First Bloom = Fresh Blossom (Live in Sunshine) First Frost = Peppered Suede Flirt = Paris Daydream = Spring Blue Skies (Fresh) French Garden = Peach Lavender French Lavender = Lavender Linens (Relax) Fresh Coconut & Cotton = Coconut & Cotton Fresh Cut Lilac = Lilac *Fresh Mint & Coconut = *Summer Terrace Fresh Water & Sea Salt = Sea to Santorini Frosted Cranberry = Merry Christmas Garden Strawberry = Strawberry = Strawberry Patch Gelato = Raspberry Peach Macaron = Sweet Macaron Georgia Peach = Georgia Market Peach = Golden Peach Sparkle = Peach Meringue = White Peach Go With the Flow = Topaz Waters = Turquoise Waters Gold Coast = Flannel Golden Pineapple Luau = Pina Colada Smoothie Green Daisy = Green Grass = Sunlit Gardens = Sunshine& Green Daisies (Happy) Havana Heat = Leather & Sweet Tobacco (Ski Den) - fine leather, sweet tobacco, caramel Heirloom Apple = Honeycrisp Apple Heirloom Garden = Tomato Garden Holly Berry Balsam = Merry Mistletoe Homemade Cookie = Merry Cookie Honeysuckle = Honeysuckle Bouquet - sweet honeysuckle, pink peony, creamy vanilla Hot Cocoa & Cream = Easter Bunny = Hippity Hop = Ohio *Iced Coconut Milk = *White Velvet Coconut *Iced Vanilla Woods = *White Birch Island Papaya = Pineapple Mango = Papaya Sunrise Island Sands = White Sands *Jade (Healing Spell) = *Incense Lakeshore Drive = Refresh = Renew & Refresh = Seashore = The Keys Lakeside = Verbena Waters Lavender Market = Peace Lemon & Fig = Sunny Fig Lemon Drops = Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemons Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemonade Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest = Sugared Lemons Love = Electric Tokyo = Hearts & Flowers = Mothers Day 2014 = Peony Petals = Pink Petals = Tokyo Petals Mad About Madrid = Tailgate II = Texas = Tobacco Flower Mahogany Teakwood = Black Teakwood = Ocean Driftwood (2014) Malibu Citrus Glow = Peach Bellini = Sweet Peach & Nectarine Mango Cilantro = Peach Cilantro Twist *Mango Dragonfruit = *Merry Mango = Sweet Maui Mango = Tiki Dragonfruit (Chase the Sun) Mango Mai Tai = Tiki Mango Mai Tai Maple Cinnamon Pancakes = Pumpkin Caramel Latte Marble Toffee = Summer Boardwalk Market Herbs = Tuscan Herbs Marshmallow Fireside = Smoked Vanilla = Trick or Treat Marshmallow Fluff = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Merry Mistletoe = Winter Wreath Midnight Blue Citrus = Snowflakes & Citrus *Mint Chocolate II (2013) =*Peppermint Brownie North Avenue Beach = Tiki Beach Orange Cream Soda = Orange Creamsicle Pacific Coast Highway = Winter Sun Pacific Ocean Air = Sea Salt & Balsam Palm Leaves = White Palm *Papaya Sunrise = *Sunset Beach (papaya, pineapple, sugarcane Paris = Pink Champagne = Sparkling Berries & Pears *Paris Café = But First Coffee = *Café Au Lait = Campsite Coffee Passionflower = Pink Apple Punch Passionfruit Cupcake = Pineapple Crumb Cake Pineapple Mango = Sugarcane Pineapple (fresh pineapple juice, mango, vine-ripened raspberry) Pink Fairy Gumdrop = Be Mine Pink Passionfruit = Red Guava Lava = Rio Red Guava Pink Watermelon = Sugared Watermelon Pomegranate = Wild Huckleberry Poolside = Sunny St. Tropez = Suntan Poolside Daydream = Sun Soaked Sandalwood Poppy Sunshine = Wild Poppies Pumpkin Coconut = Spiced Madeline = Toasted Coconut Pumpkin Milkshake = Vanilla Snowflake Pumpkin Pie = Pumpkin Vanilla = Pumpkin Vanilla Crème Pumpkin Spice Latte = Sweet Tiramisu Renew & Refresh = Seashore = Sydney Harbor (saltwater, exhilarating eucalyptus, bamboo wood) Rainforest Gardenia = Seaside Gardenia = White Gardenia Pink Lemonade Punch (Smile) = Raspberry Citrus Swirl = Sparkling Sugarplum Salted Caramel = Salted Caramel Corn Salted White Mango (I Need Vitamin C) = Sun-Drenched Mango *Sand & Sea = *Sea Salt & Sandalwood Sandalwood & Suede = Vetiver Sandalwood Sangria Berry Fizz = Sparkling Berry Fizz Sea Grass = Snap Peas Sea Island Blossom = Sunlit Cashmere Sea Island Cotton = Sea Island Shore *Sea Spray = *Turquoise Waters Sensual Amber = Sparkling Amber Sicilian Orange = Sweet Clementine Smoked Berries & Incense = Wine Cellar Snow Fall II = Spruce Snowflakes & Cashmere = Chestnuts & Argon Sparkling Limoncello = Sugared Lemon Zest Strawberry Picnic = Cotton Candy Marshmallow = Strawberry Sorbet Sugared Cherry Crisp = Sweet Cherry Pie Sun-Washed Citrus = Capri Citron = Merci Beaucoup Sunlit Cashmere = Sea Island Blossom Toffee Brittle = Toasted Coconut Vanilla & Coconut = Vanilla Snowflake Vanilla Bean = Vanilla Bean Macaron = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Warm Apple Pie = Apple Cardamom White Sage & Aloe = Wild Sage & Aloe Winter Woods = NOOK Wisteria Garden = Merci Paris / Thank You (notes: creamy vanilla, rich black currant, soft jasmine) *there are varying opinions on whether or not this is a dupe. Multiple people must confirm this is a repackaged scent. These are Repackages with a twist/change- similar but not exact dupes. SISTER SCENTS/ COUSIN SCENTS Apple Flower / Pink Apple Punch = Green Apple Champagne, Green Apple Orchard, Passionflower (?), Wasabi Apple, Weekend Apple Picking Autumn Sky / Sunlit Cedar = Crisp Morning Air Autumn Night = Evening Hearth (A is EH's big brother) Banana Pumpkin Muffin = Banana Nutmeg Bread Pudding Beach Sage & Mint = Summer Terrace (minus BS&M's sharp bergamot note) Black Sands = Perfect Waves / EM & Waves = WB Summer = Eucalyptus Mint & Rain Black Tea & Rose = Golden Amber Oak Blackberry Bramble Tea = Blueberry Pumpkin Patch Blue Orchard Skies = Country Apple (similar but NOT a dupe) Blue Sage & Sandalwood = Magnificent Milan Blueberry Pumpkin Strudel = Spiced Pumpkin Cider Bourbon Butterscotch =Hot Buttered Rum Bourbon Maple = Bourbon Sea Salt Caramel Bowties & Bourbon + Ocean Mist & Citrus = Blue Bungalow Cardamom & Suede / Holly Jolly Christmas / Autumn Nights = Autumn Day Cashmere & Oak / Winter Woods = Peppercorn Celebrate = Tis the Season (minus TTS pine note) Cinnamon Caramel Swirl = Gingerbread & Caramel Coastal Oak & Sea Salt II = Orange Blossom & Driftwood = Sea Salt & Linen Coconut Mango Cooler + Champagne Toast = Tropical Tango (Dance Til Dawn) Cotton Candy Marshmallow / Strawberry Picnic / Strawberry Sorbet = Saltwater Taffy Creamy Pumpkin = White Pumpkin (same Slatkin recipe w/ less spice than WP) Dark Kiss = Little Black Party Dress (note: both are fruity, patchouli-forward sister scents) Evening Hearth = Pumpkin Hayride (similar but NOT a dupe) Farmstand Apple + Frosted Cranberry = Iced Cranapple Fresh Linen = Sun-Drenched Linen (similar but NOT a dupe) Fresh Water & Sea Salt / Sea to Santorini = Oceanside (note: FW&SS/ STS more updated/sophisticated/feminine) Frosted Cupcake + Vanilla Pumpkin Marshmallow = Vanilla Bean Marshmallow Glazed Cinnamon Bun = Pumpkin Cinnamon Bun (NOT a dupe but could be fraternal twins) Go With the Flow / Topaz Waters / Turquoise Waters = Sea Spray & Beach Grass Gold Coast / Flannel = Black Forest Woods (?) Honey & Tangerine = Optimism Incense = Tobacco Flower *Island Waters = *Sunrise Lagoon Lavender Coconut / Lavender Sea = Lavender Woods Lilac Blossom + Provence Garden = Cucumber & Lily Mango Coconut Cooler + Pineapple Lychee Smoothie = Papaya Sunrise = Sunset Beach Paris / Pink Champagne / Pomegranate Prosecco Punch / Sparkling Berries & Pears = Cranberry Pear Bellini Pink Sands & Petals = Vanilla Beach Flower (PS&P is less intense & more floral) Praline Pecan & Cream = Pumpkin Pecan Waffles (minus PPW maple note) Pumpkin Milkshake = Vanilla Snowflake (PM is a creamier scent) Smoked Berries & Incense / Wine Cellar = Peppered Plum (NOT a dupe but could be twinsies) Spiced Pineapple Samba = Tropical Spice (SPS has a pineapple note) Spring + Luck = The Perfect Spring Vanilla Chai = Winter Latte 11/30/2022 8 Comments The updated bath and body works dupes list is here... just in time for candle daY!It's been 4 years since I started Smellthis.net. Square/Weebly, my webhosting service just DOUBLED their monthly fee. |
Archives
March 2024
CategoriesAll Bath And Body Works Boardwalk Taffy Champagne Sprinkles Cotton Candy Dupes Fragrance Glossary Fragrance Notes Fragrance Terms Frosting Fruity Gingerbread Latte Goose Creek Gourmand Lists Mandle Mushroom Wicks Puny Wick Syndrome Raspberry Repackage Repackages Salt Water Taffy Slatkin Smell A Likes Smell-a-likes Sweet Thebronzeblogger White Barn Yankee Candle |